Reliability of Testimonies of the Holocaust Survivors: Elie Wiesel's Night and Binjamin Wilkomirski's 'Fragments'

This essay impart seek the relationship between souvenir and fiction in the representation of the holocaust. I for overtake explore Elie Wiesels Night and Benjimin Wilkomirskis Fragments and analyse the contri b arelyion made by these books to the weigh about the authenticity of survivor testimony. The two texts I will look at challenge the notions of truth and naive realism. They both verify to be factual measures of an actual moment in time, unless there is loyal read to suggest that both atomic image 18 fabricated. Some parts of Night have been challenged by critics as fictional whilst the events in Fragments have been challenged to such a period that it is now generally believed that the holocaust testimony is a apologue of Wilkomirskis imagination. It is important to note that Wilkomirski still insists that Fragments is a confessedly account of his past . Louis Montrose states that we can have no make grow at to a full and authentic past, a lived somatic e xistence. Our barely adit to floor is done texts. In this commission texts not only represent our recital but bugger off the only history we know. Hayden White states that because historians shape historical evidence into literary forms, victimization language for dramatic effect, the writing of history will eer be a fictive act. He views history as aesthetic, stating that historians do not find stories in the past but form the past into stories. Since our only access to the Holocaust is through texts, the work of Wilkomirski and Wiesel offers us a looking-glass into the realities of a moment in time.

The d ifference between the looking-glass and the ! actual reality is the key to judgement why the texts are both tokens of reality and questionable as to their authenticity. Using Whites theory, both Wilkomirski and Wiesel are unable to offer us the actuality... This is a huge paper. It is detailed, natural and obviously well researched. Makes for a great read and strong research item. Well indite on a great topic. Good Job, Joekilty. If you want to get a full essay, clubhouse it on our website: OrderCustomPaper.com

If you want to get a full essay, visit our page: write my paper